The Value of Ethics in Art and Antique Collecting: The Origins of Our Experience and Our Code of Ethics

 

In the market for luxury goods, antiques and classic cars, economic value is intrinsically linked to intangible factors such as history, attribution, rarity and condition. When investments reach multi-million-euro levels, the boundary between sound asset allocation and devastating financial loss becomes increasingly narrow. Our business was founded not on mere commercial intuition, but on more than twenty years of hands on experience, gained first hand in the purest and most vulnerable role of all: that of the collector. Being collectors first and foremost means having shared the same passions and enthusiasm, but also having suffered the same setbacks in the marketplace.

It means having personally experienced the information asymmetry inherent in a sector where fraud and dishonesty often lurk behind the promise of an “easy sale”. Deception in collecting represents more than a financial loss; it amounts to a genuine betrayal of cultural heritage. The sale of furniture presented as period pieces despite having undergone extensive restoration or undisclosed recent replacements, the arbitrary attribution of paintings to renowned masters in order to artificially inflate their prices, and the fabrication of “aristocratic or museum provenances” to create a false aura of prestige are all practices that undermine trust in the market. In the art and antiques trade, dishonesty is not confined to the physical manipulation of an object. It can also be found in the details of fiscal documentation and in valuation practices characterised by information asymmetry. One unfortunately common practice among unscrupulous dealers is the issuing of invoices or receipts containing entirely generic descriptions, such as simply “Furniture” or “Painting”, while omitting the period, artist, school or condition. This is not merely a matter of administrative carelessness, but a potentially deliberate device intended to provide a legal escape route. If an invoice describes an item only as a “Painting”, should it subsequently prove to be a forgery, the dealer may attempt to defend themselves in court by arguing that the disputed object is not precisely the one sold, or that no specific attribution was ever promised.

One of the most frustrating and damaging experiences for a collector, or for a private individual who inherits an object, is to entrust it to a professional for an appraisal often a dealer who also acts as a valuer only to discover that, having recognised an opportunity for a speculative purchase, the professional deliberately understates the work's value and then offers a derisory sum, supposedly “as a favour” to the client. Such conduct runs counter to fundamental principles of law and professional ethics and may give rise to specific forms of professional liability.

 

“This awareness is the foundation of our code of ethics, which is rooted in intellectual honesty and in the duty to provide information that is as accurate, thoroughly verified and free from manipulation as possible. We are fully aware that the art market and the scholarly study of antique artworks present substantial and often considerable challenges. Attribution, dating and the art historical interpretation of a cultural object are not exact sciences; rather, they are the outcome of a complex investigative process, built up over time and often subject to academic debate. Precisely because this field is inherently complex, we believe that honesty does not mean selling absolute or dogmatic certainties where none exist. Our duty is to offer collectors more than mere commercial plausibility: it is to acknowledge the limitations of our knowledge while clearly identifying and bringing to light the established facts surrounding each individual work.”

 

Alessandro Coradi